The shipping on the book was super fast and was free with a site to store pick up. Chapters cover events of the series, both in the book world and the real world, and contemplate the authors true intentions behind each character. The 25 heartbreaking deaths of the harry potter series. I honestly think harry should have died in the books. Nov 27, 2019 instead, it killed the part of harry that wasnt truly him.
Jan 01, 2009 harry potter should have died this is a book from the people. I bought this book to help my daughter complete her harry potter book set. Rewrite harry potter and well guess which book is your. At the start of the goblet of fire movie and book, a muggle man. This is a good book filled with discussion topics that any hardcore harry potter fan would want to read about. Harry potter should have died to end the series properly. I, like everyone else who preordered the last harry potter book, read the whole. There are 450 million copies of the harry potter books worldwide. Who do you think should have died at the end of harry. Well dolores umbridge this toad of a person should have been given a death sentence.
Jun 16, 2014 harrys snowy white owl, his constant companion through his six years of school life. It was released after harry potter and the deathly hallows, and provides different points of view on certain topics that were still highly talked about after deathly hallows was released. Rowling goes beyond the epilogue info from various sources including msnbc and usa today j. Harry s adventures have already kept us entertained over the span of four books and now, in the fifth chapter, the most intricate story is given. His character already grew so much by the 7th book, and it. For those of you criticizing the book based just on its title without even reading it, you really are missing out. From wands and unicorns to spell charms and invisibility cloaks, harry potter is an epic book and movie series that explores a magical wizardry world. That should mean that the first time he was there, no one was there to save him. But when he saved harry, i started liking him a little. Studios he filled our childhood and adulthood with laughter, joy.
I was incredibly disappointed with harry potter should have died. Oct 05, 2016 the harry potter books actually have a chiastic or symmetrical plot structure. Please do not continue on here if you have not read harry potter and the deathly hallows. Whatever part of me is a realist who loves harry potter, was a bit put off that he lived to see voldemorts downfall. I think everyone who died, died for a reason, and everyone who lived, lived for a reason. Voldemort lord voldemort is a fictional character and the central main antagonist in j. Instead, it killed the part of harry that wasnt truly him.
Draco, who has joined with the death eaters, attempts to attack dumbledore upon his return from collecting a. Why order of the phoenix is my least favorite harry potter book out of the 7 video essay duration. In harry potter, the type of time travel is fixed time travel, meaning the events of the story always happened the way that we see them. Five reasons why you should read harry potter in defense. Sad because when he died it meant that the series was over killing curse harry potter neville longbottom.
The seventh book, the deathly hallows, sold 11 million copies on its first day of release. Harry potter plot holes and questions explained time. Harry potter and the halfblood prince paperback walmart. Friends have died, lessons have been learned, draco malfoy is all grown up with a child of his own, and mrs weasley said the word bitch. However, some fans have pointed out that since cedric died during the triwizard tournament, it seems like harry should have been able to see the thestrals when the carriages transported him to. Themes of bullying in harry potter, and the theme of friendship in wonder.
Sep 19, 2017 as a harry potter fan im always comparing stuff that happens in the books to the movies. Who do you think should have died at the end of harry potter. I expected the films ending to be exciting just like the last. Growing up as part of the harry potter generation taught us so many things. If harry had stayed dead, maybe we could have seen something interesting things happen with neville. A few of the topics are just plain ridiculous however, so if i were given the option id give this book 4 12 stars. Oct 19, 2012 laura owns mugglenets book harry potter should have died and we decided to debate the issues and come to our own conclusions. Rewrite harry potter and well guess which book is your favorite.
Yes, it was a crime that harry and hermione didnt end up together. Really, harry potter and the deathly hallows the deathly hallows had to be resolved with harry getting the wand. Voldemort first appeared in harry potter and the philosophers stone, which was released in 1997. We know that nothing problematic happened in the 19 years between voldemorts death and the epilogue. In the fifth book, harry potter and the order of the phoenix, harry must confront the newly resurfaced voldemort. His epithet, the bloody baron, is also an anachronism, as feudalism was not introduced in the british isles until after the norman conquest in 1066, and therefore there were no barons until this time. Now, the experts at argue passionately about what really happened and what should have happened. Hell, baby harrys first nickname is the boy who lived. By the time he died, i liked snape a lot and cried so, so much when he died.
Feb 18, 2020 the death count rose alarmingly towards the end of the series, and as it did so, it got more and more heartbreaking. Nov 20, 2017 however, some fans have pointed out that since cedric died during the triwizard tournament, it seems like harry should have been able to see the thestrals when the carriages transported him to. What purpose did her death serve except to mentally prepare the. Hell, baby harry s first nickname is the boy who lived. But the bigger problem was that harry ended up with ginny, who, sadly, had little personality. You all know harry potter, aka the boy who lived, as the hero of the famous harry potter book series by j. How harry potter changed my life opinion the guardian. So in this bizarro version of harry potter she once considered, rowling would have done more interesting thingsjust for the wrong reasons.
Harrys adventures have already kept us entertained over the span of four books and. Harry potter is actually one of the worst characters of. Harry, ron, and hermione taught us the importance of friendship. The harry potter series is one of the most popular series to be published in the last century.
Sad because when he died it meant that the series was over killing curse harry potterneville longbottom. Just as the new harry potter books came to me when i needed them most, this token seemed like a gesture from albus dumbledore himself, confirmation that i. She did a great job with all of deathly hallows, even the epilogue. He should have lived and been harry s parent, if he was extra nice.
I highly doubt the authors will achieve such a feat with this book. In the interest of continuing the hermione love, i thought we could take a look back on all the times harry potter probably would have died had he. Since the series ended in 2007, harry potter fans sometimes known as potterheads have been pouring over the books in order to find plot hole and potentially hidden backstories to their favorite characters. Harry potter is a series of fantasy novels written by british author j. Sure, im a bit harsh, but what type of teacher uses the cruciatus curse for. Rowling, harry doesnt know a lot about what goes on in the outside world. Every book in the series wasnt titled harry potter and the for nothing. The harry potter movies do, for the most part, do a brilliant job of. Dec 30, 2019 10 times harry potter should have asked for help and nearly died instead the truth of the matter is that harry nearly died on more than one occasion and half the time that was because he failed to ask for help.
Aug 10, 2010 i have to point out that if voldemort returned, it would have to be more than 19 years in the future, and harry would have to battle him as an adult. Five reasons why you should read harry potter in defense of. If, say, ron sacrificed himself to save hermione, then its a different story. Continuing with my first ever reading of the harry potter books, ive just finished the final book. The truth of the matter is that harry nearly died on more than one occasion and half the time that was because he failed to explain the situation or ask for help.
This could be any member of the order or any member of the silver or golden trio during the fight in the departm. Rowling has announced in new interviews with the today show on nbc tv today july 26 that the epilogue of harry potter and the ly hallows was vague on purpose she said it was her desire for it to be nebulous, something poetic, and that she wanted the readers to feel as if they were. After harry reawakens and narcissa malfoy lies and says he is dead, voldemort shows off by using the cruciatus curse on harrys body multiple times. Since then, there have been 5 other books released in this series, with the sixth one actually being released this week. It couldnt be real as harry thought on the next page. Preferably, a big character that would tug on many heartstrings. He still would have sacrificed himself for everyone fighting at hogwarts so they would have been protected and i have to believe somebody would have shot a spell at voldemort that was fatal. That being said, we also cant pretend that harry is an infallible leading character. One thing im thinking about a lot is voldemorts tom riddles death. And from an alchemical viewpoint, harry needed to live. This article only includes characters who were alive at some point in the text, first book upwards. The author admitted hermione should have ended up with harry, not ron. Harry potter should have died in the end as well as voldemort. The most devastating deaths in the harry potter stories.
Oct 30, 2010 friends have died, lessons have been learned, draco malfoy is all grown up with a child of his own, and mrs weasley said the word bitch. This is a great read for harry potter fans and will let them revisit their time at hogwarts. Harry potter never died, although dumbledore says in the book harry is the seventh horcrux, the horcrux is gone out of him, when harry went into the forest in the seventh book chapter the forest again he was hit with the killing curse except it hit the horcrux thats why harry was alive in the end so he had one more horcrux left to destroy. Harry potter should have died harry potter video essay youtube.
It follows the story of the boy who lived, otherwise known as harry potter himself. Jul 29, 2009 the authors previous book, s what will happen in harry potter seven, was only a nyt best seller because people were so desperate to find out what would happen at the end of the series. Though i think no one should have died, it was clear someone had to. The harry potter books actually have a chiastic or symmetrical plot structure. Jun 25, 2009 but i liked the way jkr ended harry potter. I have to point out that if voldemort returned, it would have to be more than 19 years in the future, and harry would have to battle him as an adult. Who thinks harry potter should have died in the last book. With seven books and eight movies, the harry potter universe is incredibly complicated and comes with its own diverse mythology. Jan 12, 2020 harry s determination to stop voldemort, the death eaters, or anyone else trumped everything, leading to many moments in the series where harry should have been expelled from school. Coauthor emerson spartz is a true emissary of the diehard fans, capable of hitting me with the tough, booksevenexploring. All 76 deaths in harry potter, ranked by sadness mtv. Harry potter should have died this is a book from the people. Over the thousands of pages of harry potter books and hours of their movie adaptations, funeral bells rang almost constantly.
Harrys determination to stop voldemort, the death eaters, or anyone else trumped everything, leading to many moments in the series where harry should have been expelled from school. The person harry should have felt that bond with was hagrid. The authors previous book, s what will happen in harry potter seven, was only a nyt best seller because people were so desperate to find out what would happen at the end of the series. This image explains how events that happen in the first book are mirrored in the seventh, the second mirrors. Maybe you slammed the book shut at the moment snape uttered avada kedavra. Sep 16, 20 the harry potter series is one of the most popular series to be published in the last century.
For proof, we have to look at the book harry potter and the deathly hallows because the film doesnt include this bit. Nov 03, 2011 if, say, ron sacrificed himself to save hermione, then its a different story. He should have lived and been harrys parent, if he was extra nice. The seventh and final book is out, but fans still fiercely debate the many controversial issues left unresolved. Hedwig was cruelly killed off in the beginning of book seven harry potter and the deathly hallows when she got hit by a killing curse from a death eater in the battle of the seven potters. The following article on harry potter and the bible was written several years ago after the very first harry potter book came out on video.
1280 337 382 200 636 990 961 1505 542 564 819 255 1066 1445 1591 333 941 143 1282 268 1455 1463 453 1103 1297 902 652 766 961 562 1664 1013 917 1296 1059 457 495 883 1299 644 566